Supreme Court declines Custodia master account case

The Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank’s challenge on Nov. 16, leaving in place a 2025 ruling that lets Reserve Banks reject eligible applicants.

The Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank’s challenge to Federal Reserve master account access on Nov. 16, ending the bank’s federal court case after more than six years. The order leaves in place a 2025 ruling that allows Reserve Banks to reject applications from eligible nonmember depository institutions.

The order in Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors contained no opinion. The justices therefore did not decide whether crypto-focused banks should receive master accounts or endorse the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s reasons for rejecting Custodia.

Custodia’s Supreme Court petition challenged the authority of regional Reserve Banks to deny eligible institutions access to payment services.

The case began when Custodia applied for a master account with the Kansas City Fed in October 2020. The Reserve Bank confirmed in January 2021 that the Wyoming-chartered bank was legally eligible and had “no showstoppers” at that stage.

Custodia applied for Federal Reserve membership in August 2021. The Board of Governors and the Kansas City Fed rejected the membership and master account applications on the same day in January 2023.

The Kansas City Fed described Custodia’s business model as “unprecedented” and narrowly focused on crypto assets. It found the risks “highly likely [to be] inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices” without federal supervision or stronger controls.

Custodia operates under Wyoming’s special purpose depository institution charter. The charter allows it to accept dollar deposits and provide digital-asset custody services. It requires full backing of customer dollar deposits with liquid assets and prohibits lending.

Custodia sued in federal court in Wyoming in June 2022. The district court later ruled for the Federal Reserve. On Oct. 31, 2025, the Tenth Circuit upheld that decision, ruling that Custodia was not “statutorily and automatically entitled to a master account.”

The appellate court separated two federal laws at the center of the dispute. Section 248a of the Monetary Control Act requires Federal Reserve services to be available to nonmember depository institutions at the applicable fee schedule. Custodia argued that a master account, which provides access to those services, therefore followed from its eligibility.

The Tenth Circuit ruled that Section 248a sets pricing rules and does not require a Reserve Bank to open an account. It relied on Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act, which the court interpreted as giving Reserve Banks discretion over master account applications. “The plain language of the three statutory provisions grants Reserve Banks the discretion to reject master account applications from eligible entities,” the majority wrote.

The court also cited the 2022 Toomey Amendment, which requires the Federal Reserve Board to maintain a searchable database of entities that hold or have requested master accounts. The database must identify applications as approved, rejected, pending or withdrawn. The Tenth Circuit concluded that the provision indicated Congress expected some eligible applications to be rejected.

Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented from the Tenth Circuit’s ruling. He argued that the Monetary Control Act requires access for all eligible nonmember depository institutions and wrote that the Federal Reserve had “gone too far” by claiming “unreviewable discretion over access to the nation’s financial system.”

A master account gives an institution direct access to Federal Reserve services, including Fedwire, the system used to settle large-dollar payments. Institutions without one generally use a correspondent bank or a third-party provider.

The ruling does not prevent other crypto-focused banks from applying. Kraken Financial, which has the same Wyoming charter, announced in March 2026 that it had received a master account after more than five years of regulatory engagement. The Tenth Circuit’s ruling leaves such applications subject to case-by-case review under the Federal Reserve’s 2022 guidelines.

The Supreme Court docket records no further filing from Custodia after the Nov. 16 denial. The bank has not disclosed whether it will submit a revised application, seek another charter or continue using correspondent banking services.

Reviewed and fact-checked by Alex Panasenko on November 17.

Articles by this author